Check out a few of our other taste tests: Who has the best chain chicken wings? Overall, this was a very solid sandwich but still felt lacking for some reason. I have had Jersey Mikes more than Jimmy Johns because of its close proximity to the AMC movie theater, and I was a little bit apprehensive to go somewhere I was not as familiar with. Jimmy Johns is pretty good to but doesn't come close to the size, quality and taste. Otherwise, it's not the best choice. The flavor was decent, and you get some of each ingredient in every bite because of how it's layered. So if you are in a hurry, Jimmy John's is by far your best choice. Before finding a home with TheTravel, her focus was indie publications and she has been published with Bolde, The Arts Fuse, The Silver Tongue, LI Pulse, Tattooed Heroine Magazine, and more. The bread, while not as good as the seeded kind, was still solid. No, not a pizza, but a pie with tomatoes in it. Overall, it was really dry, without any bite from any kind of sauce at all. Whether its the roast beef special at Fiores in Hoboken, or its the Soprano at Andreas Salumeria in Jersey City, theres plenty of authentic deli staples. We had the "Vito", which is their original Italian sub with salami, capicola ham, provolone, onion, lettuce, tomato, and not enough Italian vinaigrette. I apologize that I dont really have any dirt or juicy details regarding how the sandwiches are prepared. The beef is warmed up and then smothered in BBQ sauce. Oil and vinegar was used sparingly and gave the sub an extra kick. What a sad sandwich this was. We had it "Mike's Way" with onions, lettuce, tomatoes, vinegar, oil and spices. Here's a sub that doesn't let you forget Mike's commitment to quality meats and ingredients. It makes sense because Subway is cheap and consistent you know what you're going to get and you're not going to spend too much. We also had the Italian dressing on the sub, per an employee's recommendation. The subs at any ofour nomineeswould win this contest hands down, sub buns up. They now have a lot more than just their signature roast beef sandwich with horsey sauce.. Maybe it's because The Veggie is mostly made up of trans-fat-laden cheeses. At Jersey Mikes, I had to wait a few minutes before my sub was ready. The oil and vinegar added a slight tang and was used sparingly. Our poll winners for Michigan's Best sub in every region. Check out my gear on Kit: https://kit.com/mrchrisyoungIt's a battle of the subs. It wasnt stale per se, but it was as if it was just a day too old. If you didn't already know, buffalo sauces are some serious sodium offenders. Not bad. Grilled onions, peppers, mushrooms, jalapeos and of course extra melty white American cheese. The great thing about Jimmy John's is that customers can get actual sandwiches on regular bread along with subs. Rude customer service manager told me to stop talking. Fun fact: The original Jersey Mikes, then known as Mikes Submarines, opened in Point Pleasant in 1956. Which is better? Another unique thing this chain does that sets their subs apart is steaming all meats before they go on that signature bread - it adds a tenderness that's unbeatable. ", Grilled onions, peppers, and melty white American cheese. Grab some napkins and let's find out. Why? A good sandwich has the capability to make anything better, including a bad day. love JJs, marlene jones Aug 13, 2019 at 5:42 pm. Jimmy John's. The great thing about Jimmy John's is that customers can get actual sandwiches on regular bread along with subs. I was surprised by it, I liked the mixture of the meats, including the pepperoni. I was shocked when I got home and unwrapped it. They are all about giving you the sandwich the way THEY want you to have it. I ordered the Original Italian with provolone, ham, prosciuttini, cappacuolo, salami and pepperoni, and got it Mikes Way with white onions, lettuce, tomatoes, vinegar, oil and spices. Just because a sandwich shop provides custom options doesn't mean it's the best, so, which one actually is? So for the same price you can get an eight-inch sandwich at Jimmy John's or something half the size at Jersey Mike's. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. I love how thin and stringy the lettuce was. Read more: I ate chicken wings from 5 major chains, and a little-known newcomer beat out all the classics, Read more: I tried chicken sandwiches from 8 major chains, and Popeyes' was a major standout for several reasons. And last but not least, we have Primo Hoagies. We went to seven of the biggest sub chains in America to test their turkey: Jimmy John's, Jersey Mike's, Subway, Which Wich, Quiznos, Firehouse Subs and Potbelly. A few bites in, it seemed like a solid sandwich. But if youre in a jam or looking for a late night option, a sub chain might be your only choice. The tub is a salad, for those who have never been in. I'm not really sure what this means, so I'll be doing some hard hitting journalism to find out for you, because that does sound different. And what makes those different from a Jersey Mike's sub? Sometime years ago, I visited my grandfather in North Carolina, and we went over to his friends house for dinner. Customer service. Love the sisters at Bommarito's in St. Clair Shores! Frank's Red Hot Sauce, lettuce, tomato with blue cheese dressing. These subs get "grilled" (their words, not mine) if you want them hot, which means another pass in the oven. This sandwich was inspired by a request the Pepsi delivery man made in the summer of 1974. Ill be honest here. 4. jrtasoli 1 yr. ago. I have had Jimmy Johns a few times and was disappointed by the quality, but certainly not the speed. Surprisingly, one of the most popular sandwich chains is actually pretty low on the list in terms of flavor and variety. This eight-inch sandwich was $8.75. This fermented food is teeming with gut-healthy probiotics. Why? These might not be the best in the country but they are pretty dang good. Martha Sorren. You cant get it this way, you cant get it that way. Community Rules apply to all content you upload or otherwise submit to this site. PissedConsumer.com strives to provide consumers with the right information to make informed purchasing decisions. I ordered the same meal at each place: an Italian-style sub sandwich with chips, a cookie, and a drink. Amy: Agreed on the soggy bread, but it might have been because it had sat for a little while and there was a lot of sauces going on. Meet the meats of Michigan's Best sub sandwich. By the time I finished paying, my sandwich was already ready. We also appreciate that three different sizes are available, a mini, a regular, and a giant. At the Kearny location, I ordered the Italian with ham, capicola, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, oil, vinegar and oregano on the regular white roll. Christiansburg, VA 24073. This sandwich is not the kind of club you want to belong to. They use a lean turkey breast with no additives and flavorful provolone cheese. A loyalty point program and I'd get a free sub every couple weeks. The Italian comes with Genoa salami, spicy pepperoni, Black Forest ham, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, green peppers, cucumbers, oil and vinegar. Tony Dec 5, 2021 at 6:45 pm. We hit the streets and went to Jimmy Johns, then to Jersey Mikes, and two sandwiches later, picked our favorites. They also sell a smaller four-five inch sandwich for $6.29. Jimmy John's just popped up here in NJ, I'll have to do a comparison taste. Jersey Mike's is far better than JJ's in my area. I cant say I was surprised that Primos made a great sub, but its probably the closest you can get to an authentic Italian deli sandwich from chain. every day. Both Jimmy Johns and Jersey Mike have good customer service for fast food sandwich shops. We tried the "Spicy Italian", which had pepperoni, salami, and provolone cheese on their Italian white bread. $2 Off ANY Regular Jersey Mike's Sub. She can be reached at lianna.t@thetravel.com. The chain's flavors are on point and their bread is durable, but not as good as some other chains that bake their own and have a solid, dense layer between all those ingredients and potential condiments. I think what threw me off the most was the bread. We never had one bite that actually had both in it. Scheduled to Open Soon. Instead, go for the mini and you'll save yourself 1,000 milligrams of bloat-inducing and blood pressure-raising sodium. Another factor to take into consideration is allergies. Gonzo: This one was very meaty, I liked the olives, it kind of had a familiar taste to it. Subway Tuna Sandwich vs Jersey Mike's Provolone, ham, prosciuttini, and cappacuolo. Because the sub leaves off extra fatty cheeses, it ranks well in terms of calories and fat, while being more than impressive on the protein front. I know some Wawa die-hards will be shocked but this sub just wasnt very good. It has slightly less of everything, from calories to fat and sodium, and just a touch more protein. This the fifth time Ive had customer service issues, that could have been resolved w reasonable customer service and want to be the best! They also are popular for their hand cut french fries, which I'll be going back to sample for you later. It has that distinct smell of the bread, which you almost can't shake off your very clothes after a visit there. Pickled, and slightly hot, they were exactly what this, or any sub sandwich needs. The meat here is not great quality, which is a major blow. I know everyones got their favorite order, but for the sake of this debate, I stuck with the Italian hoagie. Results were generated by 134 employees and customers of Jersey Mike's Subs and 111 employees and customers of Jimmy John's Gourmet Sandwiches. Firehouse Subs is known for its toasted subs a la Quiznos (rest in peace), but for the sake of fairness, I ordered the Italian sub cold. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Advance Local. The bread was the weakest part of this sub, but it does come toasted. The Best Sandwich Chains, Ranked In Order Of Delicious To 'I'd Rather Have Pizza', A good sandwich has the capability to make anything better, The Best Pancakes At IHOP, Ranked For Scientific Flavor Purposes, While Subway may have the lead as one of the most popular, Pizza Party: Ranking Every Major Pizza Chain From Worst To Best (Sorry Not Sorry), Ranking Wendy's Best Menu Items, Including Their New Jalapeo Popper Chicken Sandwich. They had (maybe still do?) We know that you can't always make it to a locally owned restaurant, but we sincerely hope that you make a little effort to try. Thats when I buy my whole staff lunch and they seem to like it. We tried the "Italian" withGenoa salami, pepperoni, Virginia honey ham, melted provolone, Italian dressing, and seasonings, served "Fully Involved". She says, "It has the most sodium, sugar and saturated fat out of all the sandwiches. If you could not already tell, I like to channel my Italian heritage when it comes to picking subs. Blimpie has been around for more than 50 years, with locations across the country. Both are good, but I prefer Jersey Mike's over Jimmy John's. Adding ham to The Number Four tacks on about 275 milligrams of sodium and 40 calories. Access your favorite topics in a personalized feed while you're on the go. We all hope that you can actually search about Jersey Mikes Blt Sub here . Seeing "California" makes us think of acai bowls and green juicesnot a 910-calorie sub with more fat than Whopper. Yes, this Philly cheesesteak is high in sodium and saturated fat, so while lower in calories compared with some of the worst sandwiches on this list, it still doesn't make our top three choices. We're as shocked as you are, and frankly, rather disappointed it ranks so poorly against the competition. We decided to undertake this taste test of chain sub sandwiches in honor of National Eat a Hoagie Day, which this year falls on September 14. Jimmy John's, it's only a mile away from my work; to get to the local Jersey Mike's, I'd have to get on Route 1, deal with either a U-Turn, long traffic lights, and the rest of the shopping centers. Below is our breakdown of every sub on the Jersey Mike's menu, ranked from best to worst. Aside from the condiment issue, the sandwich ingredients are good and its large but pretty expensive and messy for what you get. Not going to lie, Jimmy John's really is "freaky fast". Gonzo: I like Potbelly. Frankly, Im glad its over. And to top it all off, the lettuce was a complete afterthought, with just a few strands tucked in the middle. Jimmy Johns is known for being freaky fast, and it did not disappoint. So i worked at jersey mikes not to long ago and one night me and the GM kinda got into it nothing physical or anything We received two soggy and watery tuna sandwiches so soggy we got disgusted and didnt even eat the sandwiches after two Food was wrong. The fresh factor doesn't just stop there, though - Jersey Mike's is also cooking their own roast beef and making their signature sauce with a secret oil blend and vinegar. I have had Jersey Mike's more than Jimmy John's. I just thought they started with a much lower quality meat than Firehouse or Jersey Mike's. Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Thousand Island dressing. Although picking out villains from the heroes may be hard at first glance, we here at Eat This, Not That! His friend made a tomato pie. EatThis.com is part of the AllRecipes Food Group. I also liked Jimmy Johns lettuce better because it was thinner. We tried the Italian, cold. While these might not be described as "incredible", they certainly are passable. Dont ask me how I know. At Jimmy Johns, a sandwich with chips and a drink is around $8, so you definitely get more for your money. I ordered the six-inch Classic Italian sub with ham, Genoa salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, oil, vinegar and oregano. The biggest complaint we had with this sandwich is its construction. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. There is a JJs in Monroe on US 165 north of I-20, and the other 2 are located in Shreveport. Italian: Bread: 6.1 Fillings: 5.8 Toppings: 3.6 Value: 6.4 Overall: 5.4, Firehouses Italian sub, left, and Blimpies Best. Amy: The toasting of the bread gives it a nice contrast to the tons of toppings and meat. I ordered a small Italian with prosciutto, hot capicola, Genoa salami, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, white onions, oil and vinegar. See this thread for details. It gave this sub a great punchy quality, and elevated all the ingredients with it's acidity, melding the whole thing into a good sub. This sub packs an outrageous amount of saturated fat, sodium, and calories. Subway's bread, while tasty and durable when toasted, has been limited to the same flavors for years (with the exception of a new flavor added here and there) and does have a tendency to get soggy with condiments such as oil and vinegar. Karen Kryder May 13, 2021 at 1:47 pm, Jersey Mikes is far better than Jimmy Johns! I don't understand this concept of a tea dichotomy. Gonzo: There is something about the Jimmy John's bread that Im not a fan of, I just dont really like it. But I shook my head and just dove in and took a bite. We chose to analyze the nutrition of each sub with traditional white bread and at the regular size (7-1/2 inches). Firehouse Subs also has a top-secret recipe for bread which is part of why their sandwiches always taste so fresh and delicious. The salami and ham had a slight grayish color and didnt taste like anything. The beauty of Potbelly is the distribution of the sandwich ingredients from meats to vegetables. A community to share news, events, gatherings, stories, and more for everyone that calls The Holy City (and the surrounding communities in Berkeley, Charleston and Dorchester Counties) home. The bread was pretty stale. But I had a hunch that Blimpie was going to surpass my expectations. The tomatoes and onions didnt add much here but were obviously a requirement and they didnt disappoint. : Bread: 1.2 Fillings: 1.8 Toppings: 0.7 Value: 1.1 Overall: 1.2, Subways Italian B.M.T., left, and Wawas Italian hoagie. The only problem was the Italian seasoning, someone was a little heavy handed with the oregano, which gave this sandwich a bit of a bitter, acrid taste. Every time I walk into a Firehouse Subs, I smell like one for the entire day. Ive been there early in the morning for a coffee and a breakfast sandwich, in the middle of the afternoon for a turkey sub, and late at night for snacks.