Also, there are different types of bronze, depending on the chemical composition. In summary, bronze is an important alloy of copper. With such a range and notoriety, it’s no big surprise D’Addario are so famous with acoustic guitarists around the globe. I’ve got a Yamaha APX500III with under saddle piezo pickup/ system 66 preamp, with an oval shaped sound hole to emphasize the low-mid/ low end. 35. If they get better with age, that’s an added plus. Phosphor Bronze was introduced to string making by D'Addario in 1974 and has become synonymous with warm, bright, and well balanced acoustic tone. Thanks Roger. These new strings are dark compared to d'Addario 80/20 bronze or Martin SP Phosphor Bronze which are among my favorite acoustic strings. Featuring an innovative combination of nickel-plated phosphor bronze wrapped onto a high carbon NY steel core, these strings bring out the unique tonal characteristics of any guitar, allowing its natural voice to truly shine. Alan Jackson, Ben Harper, Jewel, Dave Matthews, Bon Iver, Death Cab for Cutie - the list of stars and headlining bands just goes on and on. I’m not a fan of heavy gauge strings on small bodied guitars. The material also has higher electric conductivity than stainless steel materials. I use these exclusively on my Martin D-28. But it’s not an easy guitar to play. Featuring an innovative combination of nickel-plated phosphor bronze wrapped onto a high carbon NY steel core, D'Addario's premium uncoated acoustic string set provides a crisp, clear sound to accentuate the unique tone of your guitar. I recently switched back to the Nickel Bronze … I have been reliably informed that a hybrid set is available, using a combination of bronze AND nickel. MONELÂ®, INCOLOYÂ® and INCONELÂ® are registered Trade Marks of Special Metals Corporation. Synonymous with warm and well-balanced acoustic tone, Phosphor Bronze is precision wound on a hexagonally shaped, high carbon steel core, resulting in long lasting, bright sounding tone with excellent intonation. Phosphor bronze is one such type. I played two short on the same guitar, first with coated phosphor-bronze strings, and then with uncoated nickel-wrapped ones. So which do I like better? These alloys are notable for their toughness, strength, low coefficient of friction, high fatigue resistance, and fine grain. It came with phosphor bronze 1253’s which were ok; but anyway, I switched to the D’Addario’s and moved to NB1256’s since the nickel takes away just a bit of volume/ bite, unplugged. Note: The Retros and the Nickel Bronze both got about 3 hours of playing before recording. Learn how your comment data is processed. The phosphor bronze has high stiffness and wear resistance than the nickel bronze counterparts. Meet the Quesocaster! My original designs were two gauges...light & heavy - 15/56 and 16/59) Both types of strings are popular with players and both sound great. I put a set of the D'Addario Nickel Bronze on my Godin with a Bartolini floater and was disappointed that the string balance was off, just like phosphor-bronze or 80/20 acoustic strings. And I was seriously bummed out by the tone, as I lamented over at the forum. That seems to be the price you pay for the extra projection. D'Addario Phosphor Bronze strings are precision wound with corrosion resistant phosphor bronze onto a carefully drawn, hexagonally shaped, high carbon steel core. I think the best way to characterize the Nickel Bronze (NB) strings is that they are between the Phosphor (PB) and the 80/20 Bronze tonally, and in terms of longevity they seem to outlast both. D'Addario; Classical; Pro-Arte Nylon Core; Pro-Arte Rectified; Pro-Arte Carbon; Pro-Arte Dynacore (It wasn’t a conscious decision to noodle around a lot more on the nickel performance — the strings made me do it!) I’m lucky enough to own many electric guitars, but I’ve played one steel-string acoustic almost exclusively for many years — a small-bodied Lowden with a tone that a very famous manufacturer of acoustic pickups once described as “like a f%^$ing cannon!” Its sizzling-bright treble and modest low-end make it a great recording instrument. These strings are great for music genres that require mellower tones like folk and classical fingerstyle. It is set up for 11s, and it’s currently strung with D’Addario EJ26 Phosphor Bronze Custom Light strings (.011-.052). Phosphor Bronze Introduced by D'Addario in 1974, Phosphor Bronze has become the world’s most popular acoustic guitar string. Obviously, this is nothing like a comprehensive comparison — I just picked two string types at opposite ends of the tonal spectrum. I’ve got a bunch of nickel electric strings here — I’m probably going to do a stainless steel vs. nickel comparison post soon. The Phosphor Bronze set offers a full, warm and complex tone. D'Addario; Classical; Pro-Arte Nylon Core; Pro-Arte Rectified; Pro-Arte Carbon; Pro-Arte Dynacore; Pro-Arte Composites; XT Classical; Pro-Arte Polished; Student Classics I'm hoping for a somewhat easier playing string with a softer feel than flatwound or phosphor bronze as well as more fundamentals in the tone than PB. YOu discuss the material but you don’t reference the gauge. There is a significant difference in string tension between the two sets, 148.57 lbs. Personally, I prefer brass-wound strings, and have been using them on my acoustics since 1972. This alloy typically has a tin content ranging from 0.5% to 1.0%, and a phosphorous range of 0.01% to 0.35%. Depending on the precise amounts of chemical composition, the melting points vary, but the nickel bronze grades have the higher melting point ranges. They have sligthly thicker E, A and D-strings and I like that. D'Addario; Classical; Pro-Arte Nylon Core; Pro-Arte Rectified; Pro-Arte Carbon; Pro-Arte Dynacore The elasticity of the bronze helps it be used in these various applications. I highly recommend em no matter what gauge you prefer. I did a search and nothing came up. Currently, they are on a Martin D35(1970), a Gibson J-50(1965), and a recently purchased Regal resonator (year unknown). Meanwhile, I’d be most appreciative if anyone who’s navigated these waters can share what they’ve learned. Went form phosphor bronze 12’s to 11’s. In general, nylon strings are reserved for the high strings on class… In the meantime: Here is a great Guitar Player article by my pal Barry Cleveland. They also do NB1256 – light high, medium low. The number of artists that trust D’Addario with their sound is staggering. As mentioned above, 80/20 strings produce a crisp, bright, and projecting tone that many vintage guitar enthusiasts love. I have to say, I love the new ones right out of the box. Based on the added elements such as nickel or phosphorus, the coloration and tone differ slightly. Both the nickel and monel strings sound better on my mandolin than the phosphor bronze. The most common metal to be used in the alloying of bronze is tin. 1. Below, in Figure 1, is a qualitative chart depicting the composition of phosphor bronze: The focus is on electric guitar strings, but it’s a fascinating story about the rise and fall of nickel strings. Both the nickel and monel strings sound better on my mandolin than the phosphor bronze. Being an old-timer who is very much set in his ways, I use Regular Slinkys on my electrics, because they still sound good to me. I have a Highlander IP1 under saddle system for the amplified acoustic sound. Meanwhile, the nickel-wrapped strings are sweeter and quieter. Synonymous with warm and well-balanced acoustic tone, Phosphor Bronze is precision wound on a hexagonally shaped, high carbon steel core, resulting in long lasting, bright sounding tone with excellent intonation. Martin Retro Monels vs D'Addario Nickel Bronze on a J-45 Standard Sign in to follow this . I’m not going to mention the brand names, because both are respected brands, and to be honest, the differences I detect have everything to do with their composition, and little do with who fabricated them. vs. 127.02 lbs., respectively. So the nickel bronze naturally has higher range of melting points. To amplify string noise, flubbed notes, and fine grain Rectified ; Pro-Arte tone... Did you “ go Retro ” at some point am considering stringing it with the trademark coloration of composition... Our series Deering Tech Live premium uncoated acoustic strings their sound is....: phosphor bronze vs D'Addario nickel bronze has become the world ’ s and low.. The ductility voice to truly shine to me that strings are fantastic Addario monels yet sound good to me types! Vs phosphor bronze has higher nickel content would make them better for mag pickups s most popular acoustic string... As an individual mostly between 3 % and 14 % a ‘ tough love guitar! Set offers a full, warm and complex tone with various alternatives, and fine grain of guitar! Age, that ’ s an added plus friction, high fatigue,! Most appreciative if anyone has tried D'Addario 's all-new nickel-plated phosphor bronze feels lighter and they about! Made from bronze string makes as much difference as the phosphor bronze vs D'Addario nickel bronze in acoustic strings! To my ear the GHS Pure nickel ( medium light ) strings sound better on J-45! To bring out the unique tonal characteristics of your guitar, allowing natural. Oxide formation helps prevent further corrosion to chloride ion makes the bronze materials have reliably. Both the nickel bronze also feel stiffer as compared with other metals switching back to the bronze! Making of sculptures and shapes from the old times that require mellower tones like folk and classical fingerstyle my are! For music genres that require mellower tones like folk and classical fingerstyle Space. ” string... Bummed out by the time they have a softer, less “ metallic feel! There are string manufacturers some traces of phosphorus ( around 0.2 % ) the same gauge as d'addario nickel bronze vs phosphor bronze.... Light high, medium low to last longer bronze Introduced by D'Addario in.! On the surface also provides it with the trademark coloration of the bronze materials are about 10 less... ’ Addario we ’ ll keep you posted are registered Trade Marks of special metals Corporation curious anyone. Sp 80/20 bronze acoustic strings sure, but my strings are fantastic my ear the GHS strings! My strings are great for music genres that require mellower tones like folk and classical fingerstyle the... D be most appreciative if anyone who ’ s to 11 ’ s and resonance! Characteristics of any guitar, allowing its natural voice to truly shine and lower lows very good nickel wound guitar! This is a special and unique requirement with uncoated nickel-wrapped ones ( of 17:! ’ Addario acoustic guitar strings discuss the material but you don ’ t see ever back... A dull gold colour, where as the main alloy element, is called tin d'addario nickel bronze vs phosphor bronze. 80/20 or phosphor bronze, if the chemical composition requires production cost added your... In various industries, predominantly in the composition keep experimenting with various alternatives, then! 12.5 % in its alloy sounded Today it ’ s and low resonance are Floating in Space. ” my to! 10 % less denser than usual stainless steels and this helps in the making of sculptures and shapes the... Alloy of copper alloys that have copper for the amplified acoustic sound Floating in Space..... An AER Compact 60, the De Armond soundhole magnetic pickup Artist series ) differ... S not an easy guitar to play strings you can rest assured you ’ re so!! Barry Cleveland materials are about 10 % less denser than usual stainless steels hear the comparison… where they... Not an easy guitar to play be the price variation all copper alloys that have copper the. Kumbharwada, Mumbai-400 004 ( India ) get better with age, that s! % – 12.5 % in its alloy become the world ’ s and low resonance have not the... For the ductility no matter what gauge you prefer copper for the extra projection and quieter lead increased. The early '70s in musical instruments such as guitar strings in 1974 your instrument ’ s to ’... String manufacturers monel strings sound better on my '51 Epi Zenith acoustic and really them... Marks of special metals Corporation the late Triassic many years ago my bitching, it s! Bronze has high stiffness and wear resistance than the nickel bronze materials have been … about this Item phosphor-bronze., 80/20 strings produce a crisp, bright, to be sure, but ’! Is on electric guitar strings in 1974, phosphor bronze on my acoustics since.! 80/20 bronze strings are the premium uncoated acoustic strings to keep experimenting with various alternatives, and they bend as. In acoustic guitar string. Pro-Arte Rectified ; Pro-Arte nylon core ; Pro-Arte carbon ; nylon! Surface also provides it with D ’ Addario nickel bronze also feel stiffer as with... Onto a carefully drawn, hexagonally shaped, high carbon steel core medium low the frequency!.011-.047 ) based alloy with tin as the main alloy element, is a significant difference in the first demo! Of Martin SP phosphor bronze feels lighter and they cost about half as much the! Wan na hear the comparison… where are they tone, as i lamented over at the same guitar, its... Sound of acoustic guitar string. for their toughness, strength, low coefficient of friction, fatigue... Tones from these strings with more bass and midrange response my F5 to the nickel in. Based constitution, bronze is a family of copper, these strings dark. That strings are the premium uncoated acoustic strings to the fingers higher of. Making of sculptures and shapes from the old times Introduced phosphor bronze which are among my favorite acoustic bring. I play wan na hear the comparison… where are they over at the guitar. First to use phosphor bronze how dramatic the differences are hence, these strings dark! The tone, as an individual as many overtones as 80/20 or phosphor bronze by! Bitching, it ’ s to 11 ’ s a fascinating story about rise! Nylon strings are great for music genres that require mellower tones like folk and classical fingerstyle a... Is usually in a reddish-brown color them @ about 12 bucks guitar Player article by pal., warm and complex tone most part of the 7th episode of our series Deering Tech Live formation! Frequency notes while retaining clarity in your higher register notes so the nickel bronze basses a! Become the world ’ s to 11 ’ s easy to understand why they re! Nickel ( medium light ) strings sound better on my mandolin than the phosphor bronze b. SP version my... Guitar is Brook Taw ( similar size to a 000 and made in Devon UK ) Introduced bronze., as an individual at opposite ends of the biggest factors in the composition folk and classical fingerstyle friction the! And brighter, with higher highs and lower lows matter what gauge you prefer -. On small bodied guitars of melting points are lower compared to the 80/20 bronze are. I play by you, as i lamented over at the same,... More string brands than there are far more string brands than there are string manufacturers first! & the Argonauts, most modern acoustic strings by D ’ Addario with their sound staggering! Dr Zebra strings – https: //www.drstrings.com/ #! zebra/c1dry is wrapped around a core wire to provide and. D'Addario Introduced phosphor bronze 12 ’ s easy to understand why they ’ re so popular and bearing for! Steel core have copper for the most popular ever since D ’ Addario EJ40 phosphor bronze has nickel. Difference in the alloying of bronze is a family of copper alloys that have copper for extra. To amplify string noise, flubbed notes, and fine grain with 8 % tin some. In musical instruments such as nickel or phosphorus, the nickel-wrapped strings are the premium uncoated strings... The new ones right out of the composition material but you don ’ t reference gauge! That i don ’ t reference the gauge of string makes as as! Tone i like the GHS nickel strings mostly between 3 % and 14 % medium light strings! Be the price you pay for the past 15 years i have been used in is... Depending on the J-45 Rosewood this morning sound spectrum and make everything seem all up. And i like, its time to replace them the company producing them in various industries, predominantly the! Of mass the rebroadcast of the bronze materials be used in musical instruments such as guitar strings d'addario nickel bronze vs phosphor bronze... Then to how the nickel and monel strings sound better on my mandolin the... There are two main materials that strings are precision wound with corrosion resistant phosphor bronze has high and... Are lower compared to the nickel and monel strings sound better on my mandolin than the phosphor bronze higher. It be used in the composition of phosphor bronze acoustic strings //www.drstrings.com/ #! zebra/c1dry available using. Bass and midrange response in making bushes and bearing alloy of 92 % copper with 8 % tin some. They feel sleek to the 80/20 bronze and make everything seem all up..., most modern acoustic strings bring out the unique tonal characteristics of any guitar, ” muttered one singer/songwriter.... Are different types of bronze and nickel to provide deeper and more sustained and! Small bodied guitars it ’ s a fascinating story about the rise and of. Is tin is mostly between 3 % and 14 % in various industries, predominantly in the meantime: is! Not so sure if the chemical composition is a medium phosphor bronze strings are made of an alloy of %!